Amy
 Feb 27, 2025

nick
 Feb 22, 2025
great show and I love the banter between the two hosts

a listener
 Oct 11, 2024

 Apr 24, 2024

JJ
 Mar 6, 2024

 Jan 4, 2024

sabrina
 Nov 26, 2022
I'm a little sick of all the unsolved murders. count me out. you guys used to be better. not to mention the captain with all his ununderstanding comments, G, it's not a "to make fun of" subject.

Griffin in Vegas
 Jun 25, 2022
My favorite true crime podcast. I used to listen to Sword and Scale but I couldn't overlook the hosts behavior anymore. Nick and the Captain don't lash out against their fans like he does. They cover each case in more depth, even going so far as do do multiple parts if necessary. Highly recommend this podcast.

 Jan 14, 2022

PFC Jack Squat
 Sep 9, 2021
I disagree. these guys do the best breakdown of a case. I'll hear the same case on a similar podcast and get less out of it. one of the, if not thee O.Gs and still one of the best crime pods.

 Apr 29, 2021
God these guys are annoying. They think they're detectives and are going to solve the case.

 Apr 1, 2021

 Mar 31, 2021

bob
 Mar 4, 2021
the 1 guy thinks he know more than investigators That's kinda annoying

 Jan 18, 2021

Love/Hate
 Jan 16, 2021
Love the stories and the research that goes into each podcast. But I absolutely hate the captain. His comments are childish and he really adds nothing to the podcasts...he's not funny, and most of the time he sounds like an idiot. 🤷‍♀️

ANM
 Apr 6, 2020

Laura R
 Feb 4, 2020

Aileen
 Jan 25, 2020
Love this podcast, it's very well produced and researched. I'm even a little bit partial to the captain's banter, even though I'm normally not into bantery true crime podcasts. Keep it up guys!

 Jan 15, 2020

nigel
 Jan 6, 2020
love it , had to go to stitcher for earlier shows but it is worth it !