Lance
 Jan 12, 2024
Worst true crime podcast I've ever listened to, imagine two of the most vapid, woke, unfunny people trying to make jokes whilst watching other people's content. That's what this is.

Stephanie
 Oct 22, 2023
Initially they were the best thing and I thought that they were a breath of fresh air and people we could trust to do right by others. However, it seems that P cannot take criticism, or own up to his mistakes, and G stays silent on the issues that are being raised currently. I am severely disappointed. I am unsubscribing and I canceled my patreon. Be better, do better.

Patrick allegedly abuses staff
 Oct 10, 2023
I used to enjoy the show but after finding out how the network is being run and about Patrick's behavior toward staff and the podcasters I had to unsubscribe and cancel my Patreon membership.

Podcast Republic User
 Jan 13, 2022
Finally unsubscribed after 146 episodes. Listening to them cackle at their own stupidity in between details of horrific murders just feels gross. The concept of covering documentaries is great, but their coverage of true crime is so trashy.

Suz
 Dec 6, 2021
Love this podcast... They are themselves and don't care what anyone thinks about them. So funny also!

kb
 Sep 15, 2021
WHY 👏 ARE 👏 THEY 👏 ALWAYS 👏 YELLING

hayley
 May 11, 2021
this used to be my VERY FAVORITE podcast but now I can only listen to an ep or two at a time? why? I can't stand his incessant laughing at EVERYTHING she says. I don't think it used to be this bad! I use to listen to this for hours at a time at work but sorry Patrick, Gillian ain't that funny! it drives me crazy. it is a funny podcast, interesting, etc but Patrick, c'mon. you are much funnier than her. she doesn't laugh at your jokes like that.

Gina
 Mar 8, 2021
Overall, love the pod, but docking a star because they have more ad breaks than any other podcast! Patrick's screeching is especially out of control in the ads and the Golden Girls theme song lead-in now makes me cringe.

 Mar 4, 2021

MAB
 Aug 28, 2020
Great Pod! I feel like these two are my spirit animal. They talk about crime documentaries, but don't worry.... you don't have to watch them to enjoy this podcast.

 Jul 14, 2020

 Sep 24, 2019

Violet
 Jun 10, 2019
These are my people! True crime made funny! I love this podcast and for people who like true crime I recomend it.

Sarah H
 May 23, 2019
love. so funny, so sincere. just love P&G- definitely recommend

 May 18, 2019

Jolisa
 Feb 26, 2019
I love this podcast but really, am I the only one who thinks it's important to focus on how attractive Ted Bundy was to dispel the notion that nice looking guys can't be evil?

Christine
 Feb 9, 2019
I love this podcast. These two are hysterical. the one thing I hate is when Patrick says Byyyyeeee. Come on.

 Nov 12, 2018
Literally obsessed.