Dec 7, 2022

 Jun 4, 2020

 Dec 9, 2019

 Sep 22, 2019

 Sep 8, 2019
Unfocused and full of conspiracy theories. Host reopens old wounds yet offers nothing new

 Sep 7, 2019

 Jul 21, 2019

Gilbert
 May 22, 2019
Both seasons were worth my time.

 Apr 17, 2019
almost no new information about the case, and way too much time given to crackpot theories. waste of time.

 Mar 15, 2019

wtfmedic
 Feb 6, 2019
has me on my seat with zodiac and monster was great

 Jan 29, 2019

Jenny J
 Jan 28, 2019
meh. not as good as Up and Vanished

 Jan 11, 2019

ThePaulGuy
 Jan 9, 2019
Excellent production. Keeps you pulled in and looking forward to the next episode.

 Oct 24, 2018

Greg H.
 Sep 7, 2018
This is one of my favorite true crime podcasts. The in-depth reporting is absolutely riveting and the details presented are very balanced and non-biased.

A Podcast Republic user
 Aug 22, 2018

James S
 Aug 6, 2018
Not as comprehensive as Up and Vanished, but this podcast is about informing people not solving the case. Some shortcomings of this podcast stem from the tight deadlines Mr. Lindsay seems have been stuck to as the season is less cohesive.

True Crime Podcast Fan
 Aug 2, 2018

A Podcast Republic user
 Jul 27, 2018