Max M
 Jul 1, 2025
Lots of the one-star reviews here seem to be given for reasons other than the quality of the podcast, which itself is very interesting and enjoyable.

 Aug 5, 2024
Flouting opinion as fact through the guise of being prosecutors. These two are dangerous.

 Jul 11, 2024

C West
 Jun 13, 2024
I had such high hopes for this. they repeat themselves so much. one topic, one idea is repeated ad naseum. she says something, he repeats, she then repeats. get to the point!

KG
 Apr 6, 2024
Oof. I was enjoying the host chemistry and interesting perspective on cases until I discovered their identities as Alice Shih Lacour and Brett Talley. Google them; I'm repulsed.

 Nov 12, 2023

bobbie
 Sep 6, 2023

 Jun 24, 2023

once a fan
 Jul 26, 2022
lol of course you hid your last names, you're monsters.

 Apr 19, 2022
MAGA supporters who purposely hid their full names to avoid being googled and outed as the terrible people they are. Google Brett Talley.

Giorgia
 Sep 10, 2021
I know nothing about American law (I know nothing about my country's law system as well), but I find extremely interesting how both hosts explain the ins&out of the justice system and how inquests are carried out in real life!

Ethan P
 Aug 30, 2021
Love that they focus on unsolved cases. Hosts have great chemistry. They seem willing to entertain theories other podcasters would avoid. They are okay with the mundane answer or ones that don't keep the victim squeaky clean.

 Mar 31, 2021

MBinAZ
 Feb 10, 2021
This has turned into one of my top 3 favorite podcasts. Brett and Alice really go in depth and take a good look at the cases they cover.

Mike
 Sep 16, 2020

Krystal
 Aug 13, 2020