Till Death Do Us Part Podcast

By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

Listen to a podcast, please open Podcast Republic app. Available on Google Play Store.

Category: Comedy

Open in Apple Podcasts

Open RSS feed

Open Website

Rate for this podcast

Subscribers: 8
Reviews: 0


They've been married for 16 years. She's intrigued by true crime. He couldn’t care less. Can their marriage survive a podcast? Or will it end in MURDER?!

Episode Date
Jerry and Rebecca Barker

 Most men just want peace and quiet while taking an afternoon nap in their easy chair. Poor Jerry got his wish. In this episode Melissa tells Daniel about a second chance at love that ultimately turns fatal.

For that one person who hates factoids the case begins at- 11:00

Support the show
Sep 27, 2022
Dan and Nancy Brophy

Welcome to the most requested case by our 11 listeners. You're welcome.
Melissa finally tells Daniel about the case that dominated the news feeds earlier this year (2022).  When the wife writes an essay titled 'How to Murder Your Husband' how could she not be the murderer? Or can her unfortunate body type be the key to unlocking the mystery? Let us Know.

Support the show
Sep 20, 2022
Alexander Crittenden and Laura Fair

Ready to take a trip back in time? Join Daniel as Melissa dusts off the old flux capacitor and gets their old 2011 suburban up to 88 miles per hour and lands in the 1800’s. Just in time for the California silver mining boom. 

Case begins at 8:25. You’re welcome!

Support the show
Sep 13, 2022
Tony and Lilius Landrum Smith

This case is heartbreaking on so many levels. 
How can a love so new turn so evil so quickly? 

The case of Tony and Lilius Landrum Smith begins at -10:00

Support the show
Sep 06, 2022
Afternoon Delight- Bradley and Christe Chen Dawson

When the perfect honeymoon destination turns into a living nightmare.

Support the show
Sep 03, 2022
Bruce and Judy Moilanen

This might be one of the dumbest husbands we’ve ever had the privilege of covering. Another murder that has you scratching your head and saying, “but why though”? Divorce is always the better option.
Upper Peninsula where you at?

Melissa’s case begins - 10:00

Support the show
Aug 23, 2022
Afternoon Delight- Lee and Dawn Wynn

Join Daniel as Melissa tells him a case that is unfolding as we speak

Support the show
Aug 19, 2022
Carey and Robin Heidt

Melissa tells Daniel a case filled with lust, greed, and sibling rivalry that leaves you wondering, was the guilty person prosecuted? Or did the town gossip put an innocent resident behind bars?

Support the show
Aug 09, 2022
We have an announcement!
Aug 02, 2022
Scott and Karen Waltz Roston

Another murder on the high seas, but this one will have you scratching your head and saying “what”?

Daniel has factoids about the origins of common sayings - 1:49
The Poisoners Cabinet ad-  11:00
The case of Scott and Karen Waltz Roston- 11:55

Jul 26, 2022
Charlie and Christine Billis

In this episode Melissa tells Daniel a case out of picture perfect Vermont. Where a tragic accident turns into to something much more sinister. Moral of the story,  keep your big mouth shut!  
*Be warned, we talk about movies a lot in this one.

Annoying banter at the beginning… again!
Daniel has bird factoids- 3:36
Conspiracy Couple Ad-15:40
The case of Charlie and Christine Billis- 16:30

Jul 12, 2022
Dirk and May Greineder

Just when you thought it was safe to go for a walk in the park with your spouse. Melissa tells Daniel a tragic case from one of the most affluent zip codes in the US. 

5:10-  Daniel has factoids
16:00- Ad for Military Murder Podcast
17:00- The case of Dirk and May Greineder

Jun 28, 2022
Thomas Toolan and Beth Lochtefeld

On the small exclusive island of Nantucket, a beautiful woman was murdered. This shattered the typically safe feeling of the residents where most leave their doors and windows unlocked. Could she have been murdered by a stranger or someone she knew?

Jun 14, 2022
Vince and Elizabeth Marinello

In celebration of Till Death Do Us Part Podcast’s first year , Melissa takes Daniel back to where it all started, New Orleans.  But, as we have been saying over the last 12 months, divorce is always a better option to murder. However, some spouses don't seem to agree. 

May 31, 2022
Michael and Amy Archer Gilligan

Our dream was to retire to a nice group home, but Daniel is having second thoughts after this case.

Support the show
May 24, 2022
David and Patty Swinehart

When Pottstown’s most famous son is brutally murdered and placed in the backseat of his car, is his soon to be ex-wife the murderer, the mastermind, or simply an innocent spouse.

May 17, 2022
Michael and Jan Roseboro

In 2008, the body of Jan Roseboro was found floating facedown in her backyard pool in the rural Amish county of Lancaster, Pennsylvania.  Was Jan’s death an accident? Caused by a heart attack? Could Jan have been brutally robbed and murdered while star gazing for nothing more than a ring and a watch? Or, was Jan killed by someone she knew and trusted? Someone she promised to love, honor and cherish for the rest of her life? You be the judge. 

May 10, 2022
Allan and Betty Gore with Pat and Candy Montgomery Part 2

Who murdered Betty Gore? The conclusion that will leave you saying “what the heck just happened?”

May 03, 2022
Allan and Betty Gore with Pat and Candy Montgomery Part 1

In the year 1980, a brutal murder rocked the small town of Wylie, Texas and threw the good people of this rural community into a media firestorm. Listen as Melissa tells Daniel part 1 of this soon-to-be famous case once more. You can thank Hulu for that.  And we have our first ad! Thank you to our podcast friends at Wife of Crime. We are riding your coat tails all the way baby!

Apr 26, 2022
Mark and Marybeth Harshbarger

When a hunting trip in Newfoundland goes horrifically wrong, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police decide the evidence points to an accident. But Melissa let’s Daniel in on the secrets of the not-so-perfect marriage. Does the evidence only point to accidental death or could this case be considered the “most perfect murder”?

Apr 19, 2022
John and Becky Cotton

Back in the good old days, women were not allowed on juries and some aspect of truth can become a legend. Melissa dives deep into the lore of "Bec's hole" straight out of South Carolina. Daniel comments as well.

Apr 12, 2022
Tom and Juanita Richardson

Wanna go for a hike? Melissa takes Daniel way up North to the Upper Peninsula of Michigan to beautiful Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore. Melissa dives into the first known case of a death caused by a fall from the sandstone cliffs. Was it a horrific and tragic accident? Was it the act of suicide? Or was it MURDER?!!! Take a listen and follow along with our resident pessimist.
PS- Daniels factoids have to do with adult aerobics positions. You’ve been warned.

Support the show
Apr 05, 2022
Claus and Sunny von Bulow

Join Daniel, as Melissa walks him through the ends and outs of one of the most prolific cases of wealth and privilege over the last century. But the question remains to this day, does money buy you justice? Take a listen and see if you can possibly solve the mystery in the mansion. 

Mar 29, 2022
Chris and Karon Pugh

The MacArthur’s are going international. Melissa is telling Daniel a horrific tale of murder straight outta Wales. If this case doesn’t have you seeing red than there’s something seriously wrong with you. 

Mar 22, 2022
Randy and Teresa Stone

Listen as Melissa tells Daniel another case of marriage, adultery, and murder. But this time, it’s not the spouse who does the killing. But could they be guilty of conspiring? I guess you’ll have to press play and find out.

Mar 15, 2022
Adam and Rose Chase

Melissa tells Daniel a case that just might leave you feeling a little suspicious of your neighbor’s burn pile.

Mar 08, 2022
Eric and Ann Miller

Join Daniel as Melissa tells him the case of a seemingly perfect marriage, with a seemingly perfect couple. But we all know, looks can be deceiving.

Mar 01, 2022
Erasmus Trout and Zona Heaster Shue “The Greenbrier Ghost”

 Join Daniel as Melissa takes him on a journey back in time, before the turn of the century to good 'ole West Virginia. The details of this historical case are so unique that even Daniel might start to believe. In what you might ask? Listen and find out. 

Support the show
Feb 22, 2022
Michael and Sherri Dally

The MacArthur's head back to beautiful and sunny California where the women are blonde and the murders are dark and sinister. Join Melissa as she tells Daniel about a tale as old as time, a marriage full of sex, drugs, and murder.

Support the show
Feb 15, 2022
Todd and Amy Mullis

On a farm in Iowa, one of the greatest mysteries of the last decade unfolded. Was this murder or possibly an accident. We came to our own conclusions. Will you? Another MacArthur murder mystery for your listening pleasure.

Feb 08, 2022
Quickie with our listeners #3

In the mood for another quickie? Daniel and Melissa sure are.

Support the show
Feb 01, 2022
Daniel and Loretta Burroughs

Till death do us part takes on a whole new meaning for Daniel and Loretta Burroughs, you will never look at closet air fresheners the same after listening to this episode.

Jan 25, 2022
Bob and Martha Ann McClancy

This episode should really make you angry. When two professional liars get together and the life of a good person is lost, how far can they take it? How about all the way up to the federal government.

Jan 18, 2022
Dan and Betty Broderick Part 2

As the Dan and Betty saga wraps up, it leaves you trying to decide if Betty is totally crazy or perhaps did Dan deserve it?

Jan 11, 2022
Dan and Betty Broderick (Part 1)

Betty freakin' Broderick, need we say more?

Jan 04, 2022
Quickie with our listeners #2

We enjoyed our first quickie so immensely, that we decided to do it again. We do talk about ourselves a lot. You have once again been warned. 
*If you have a story you would like us to share, please email to tilldeathdouspart@att.net

Dec 29, 2021
Quickie with our listeners #1

Welcome to our very first quickie. Just sit back, relax, and enjoy the ride. We talk about ourselves a lot. You have been warned.
*If you have any stories you would like to share, please email them to tilldeathdouspartpodcast@att.net

Dec 28, 2021
Bruce and Janice Dodson

It's always a bad thing when a hunting trip goes sideways especially after only having been married for 3 months. Enjoy Daniel's factoids on Christmas movies.

Dec 22, 2021
Christopher and Theresa Lockhart

When a wife goes missing, sometimes the map left to find her just leaves a person hanging.

Dec 14, 2021
Marty and Glenna Duram

When a loved one is murdered and the only eyewitness (and possible suspect) claims amnesia, sometimes the case is left up to the bird.

Dec 07, 2021
Rodney and Morgan Metzer

Gaslighting and faking cancer to become a hero to your ex-spouse never works out...not even for Batman.

National Domestic Violence Hotline
1 800 799 SAFE (7233)

Women in Distress- 24 hour hotline
1 954 761 1133

Till Death Do Us Podcast on Instagram
We are here to help as well

Nov 30, 2021
Cork and Lucille Miller

Accident, murder, or suicide? Your guess is as good as ours.

Nov 23, 2021
Mark and Kathy Wangler

When your spouse brings killer gas into your room, usually it means they had some rough Mexican food for dinner, but in this case it was odorless, tasteless and colorless and quite literally a killer.

Support the show
Nov 16, 2021
Jacques and Candice Mossler (Part 2)

Arrest and trial and a verdict! Oh my!

Nov 10, 2021
Jacques and Candace Mossler (Part 1)

Money and murder and incest oh my!

Nov 09, 2021
Aaron and Naomi Estes

In a world full of never ending excuses, will a man of God be able to use amnesia to get out of murder? 

Nov 02, 2021
Jeremy and Julene Simko

Alright, this one should make everyone a little bit uncomfortable.

Support the show
Oct 26, 2021
Race and Brigida Uto

In episode 27,  Melissa tells Daniel about a marriage and a lovely case of poisoning. Does the victim survive? Listen and find out. 

Oct 19, 2021
Robert and Natalie Wood Wagner (part two)

In the second half of the tragic Natalie Wood case, Melissa and Daniel dig into the versions of what happened that fateful night and the theories surrounding her death.

Oct 13, 2021
Robert and Natalie Wood Wagner (part one)

In this episode, Melissa tells Daniel the beginning of the tragic Hollywood story of Natalie Wood and her mysterious death that stumps experts and still rocks the public to this day.

Oct 12, 2021
The Lady in White

Happy Hallowiener! Welcome to our one and done Halloween episode. Daniel takes us on a journey through candy factoids, while Melissa tells you the legend of The Lady in White, including ghostly tales of her spirit around the world. Don't be afraid, it's mostly crap. 

Oct 05, 2021
Mary Elizabeth Wilson "The Merry Widow of Windy Nook"

In this episode Daniel begins with a flare up of factoids that discuss the benefits of going commando in bed. Melissa tells Daniel the fascinating case of a polyamorous relationship that began around 1915 and lasted four decades, but by the 1950's, two were dead and a true Black Window eventually claimed four victims thrusting the quaint English village of Windy Nook into the national spotlight.

Sep 28, 2021
Lonnie and Micki Kanesaki Kocontes

Melissa tells Daniel about another tragic case of a murder on the high seas. Why is it that the kindest people are always the the ones to lose their lives way before their time?

Sep 21, 2021
Stephen and Jody Ann Scharf

Episode 21 is a true cliffhanger! As Melissa takes Daniel through this gruesome and crazy case, it reveals that even the top experts  can disagree on what really happened. 

Sep 14, 2021
Re-visiting our cases from episodes 1-19

In honor of episode 20 and Daniel's bad memory, Melissa is revisiting episodes 1-19 and discussing the high points from those crazy cases.

Sep 08, 2021
Fred and Walburga "Dolly" Oesterreich

This case might be the craziest yet. Listen as Melissa tells Daniel about a ménage a trois, but only two people are aware of the arrangement. Will Daniel ever let Melissa buy a house with an attic again?

Aug 31, 2021
Jamie and Judy Orr Baldwin

Let's take a trip to South Carolina where the Harley's are slow but the murder's are fast. Join Daniel as Melissa tells him about a case of 2nd chances that lead to the ultimate betrayal. Don't believe everything you read on social media. Will Daniel ever buy a new jeep for fun or murder?

Aug 17, 2021
Paul and Linda Kincade Curry

Nicotine kills, literally! Melissa tells Daniel about a case that had gone cold for almost 20 years. Thanks to a cold case detective, who didn't let the opinions of others sway her, the case was solved. Will Daniel choose the poison route when he finally murders Melissa? I guess we'll soon find out. Make sure to subscribe, rate, and review our humble little podcast.

Aug 10, 2021
Anthony Fertitta and Cindy McKay

In this sweet 16 episode, Daniel keeps Melissa up to date on the habits of couples. So, what are you comfortable doing in front of your spouse? Melissa then takes Daniel through the dating saga of Anthony Firtitta and Cindy McKay ultimately leading to betrayal and murder.

Aug 03, 2021
Todd and Jenae Chance

In celebration of the 15th episode, Melissa is telling Daniel their very first home town case. Bakersfield, California, this one's for you. 

Jul 26, 2021
Michael and Cindy Reese

Join us as Melissa gives Daniel an update on episode 4 of the tragic cruise ship case of Kenneth and Kristy Manzanares. Melissa then tells Daniel all about a murder that shook the small faith- based community of Morris, Alabama. When a pastor breaks up a marriage with his penis, someone in the love triangle is going to receive their divine retribution. But it won't be the victim. 

Jul 22, 2021
Dr. Herman Tarnower and Mrs. Jean Harris

Could you spend fourteen years as a second fiddle in a relationship? Daniel and Melissa don't think they could play in that band, no matter how much they got laid...paid. Join Daniel as Melissa tells him about a suicide attempt gone horribly wrong which begs the question; is a young mistress such a good idea?

Jul 14, 2021
Jack and Christina Kettlewell

Guess what Canada? Daniel and Melissa didn't solve the mystery of the eight day bride case! Will Melissa be renting a secluded cabin this summer? Perhaps, but Daniel won't be going.

Jul 08, 2021
Cody and Jordan Graham Johnson

How long did you wait? In episode 11, Melissa tells Daniel the disturbing marital story and murder of a newlywed spouse who never got to consummate his marriage. Does Daniel think his death was an act of murder, or just a kinky tryst gone wrong? Listen and find out.

Jul 03, 2021
Phil and Brynn Hartman

We've made it to double digits! Episode 10! Listen as Melissa breaks Daniel's heart and finally has the courage to tell him that one of his favorite SNL cast members is actually deceased. How did it happen? Why did it happen? All of Daniel's questions will be answered. But if he asks too many, well, we all know what Melissa might do....

Support the show
Jun 24, 2021
Greg and Pamela Smart Part 3

Melissa finally bids goodbye to the infamous murder of Greg Smart orchestrated by his Hairband loving wife. Listen to Melissa as she takes Daniel through the trial that starts the obsession of tabloid television.
Just a heads up; there are 3 “F” bombs in transcripts Melissa reads.

Support the show
Jun 21, 2021
Greg and Pamela Smart Part 2

Melissa tells Daniel part two of a three part series of the  Murder of Greg Smart. In this episode Melissa takes a deep dive into the actual murder and aftermath in the days leading up to the arrest of Pam's sixteen year old lover. Is Daniel glad he was more focused on getting a car and license than getting laid at sixteen? Yes.

Support the show
Jun 14, 2021
Greg and Pamela Smart Part 1

This case was so crazy that we had to split it into three parts. In episode 7, Melissa takes Daniel back in time into the bad and bodacious 80's and introduced the case that shocked the nation. It gave us Court TV, Inside Edition, and put Phil Donahue on the map. You'll think differently the next time you hear "Too Hot for Teacher" by Van Halen.

Support the show
Jun 11, 2021
James and Rebecca Bargy

This case is a tiny one but leads to discussions of different sexual lifestyles of couples that we all probably know. They could be that old couple that live next door to you. Either way, Daniel won't look at pineapples the same.

Jun 05, 2021
Marjorie Nugent and Bernie Tiede

In episode 5, Melissa introduces Daniel to the unusual relationship between a younger mortician and a wealthy elderly woman. The story begs the question; who is taking advantage of whom. Daniel deleted the deep freezer from Melissa's amazon cart after learning about this case.

Jun 02, 2021
Kenneth and Kristy Manzanares

Wanna go on a cruise? Melissa takes Daniel on a 1st class sailing adventure through the relationship and ultimate sinking of Kenneth and Kristy's marriage. Daniel and Melissa discuss their own experiences cruising. The good, the bad, and the soft serve.

Support the show
May 30, 2021
David and Clara Harris

In episode 3,  Melissa takes Daniel on a wild car ride through a deceptive marriage  where appearances mean everything but forsaking all others does not. Can Daniel stop thinking about doughnuts, cars, and women drivers long enough to absorb this case? Or should Melissa just put him out of his misery now. Listen and find out.

Support the show
May 27, 2021
Steven and Lana Sue Clayton

Being the second episode, Melissa takes Daniel on a big dive into a little case. The water might feel like urine but at least Melissa has not shot Daniel in the head with a crossbow...yet.

May 26, 2021
The Murders of Lonie and Theresa Moity

Listen to married couple Daniel and Melissa stumble through their very first episode as real life podcasters. Melissa's job is to shock and get reactions from Daniel as she tells him the story of the New Orleans trunk murders of 1926. Should they have just taken up golf or tennis? You be the judge.

May 23, 2021